TOOLS for HOPE ANNUAL REPORTS |
2021 Annual Report
Tools for Hope Inc. 2021 Review
Introduction
We are grateful for your continued support for Tools for Hope. The small-holder farmers we mentor made significant advances in their overall welfare. We, in the USA, and they in Rwanda learned some important lessons in 2021 on our journey to their sustainable, stable lifestyle.
They continued to make improvements in agricultural productivity as well as in food / crop preservation techniques. Intercropping, mulching, no-till farming, and rotational crop planting are now commonplace with our farmers. Their access to clean water has dramatically improved. Despite the problems presented by COVID-19 they are still in good, overall health.
We ended our relationship with Frank Mutesa because of failures related to candor in his monthly reports and, to his fiduciary responsibilities to the farmers. The farmers, under his guidance sold their motorcycle taxi at a loss and without TFH knowledge. We are still investigating the issue(s). In 2022, in response to this issue, TFH will institute an in-country audit function to ensure proper process are being followed. Additionally, taskings will be detailed and in writing.
Our new Rwandan staff-member, Diane Uwamahirwe, took over mentoring the Twisungane Cooperative in mid-year. She is an Agribusiness and Environment Specialist with a BS (honors) in Agribusiness and, is completing her master’s degree. She has helped us to find important challenges that need to be addressed. Additionally, she is preparing the farmers to meet those challenges.
We are developing a new website (https://toolsforhope.org/). Our goal is to help keep you better informed of our activities. Please send your suggestions for improving the website to tools4hope@gmail.com
Achievements
In January, at its quarterly meeting, the Tools for Hope, Inc. (TFH) Board of Directors decided to extend repayment of the loan for the twenty-two goats to eleven Twisungane families until March 2022. They will have an extended time in which to raise more goats making loan repayment easier for them i.e., each family will sell two of their goats to repay their loan.
The loan, as all such TFH loans, is interest free and we exercise no recourse for non-payment. Their loan repayment funds are directed to a local bank account to be used for future loans for the farmers’ projects. Therefore, it benefits the farmers to repay their loans as best they are able.
The no-till farming trials were successful. Now the farmers are using the technique where workable. The technique is particularly helpful to the farmers because they lack powered agricultural machinery such as tractors, plows, planters, etc.
They are reviving and using traditional preservation methods such as sun drying, salting, and cooling by digging a hole to store crops like cassava and potato and milling some crops into flour to be used later.
Food preservation for the farmers is critical to their well-being. Rwandans, in general, do not favor preserved foods. Consequently, more food spoils and is discarded than is consumed annually in Rwanda. Immediately after crops are harvested food is plentiful and inexpensive. Without effective food / crop preservation techniques as time passes the reverse is true. Food preservation helps the farmers’ families have affordable, proper nutrition between harvests.
Diane is working to help solve a fundamental cause for subsistence farmer poverty. The farmers we mentor do not own their farmland. They rent. A fundamental precept in wealth creation is to make / grow products at an overall cost below market value. Effective free enterprise dictates that the farmers own their means of production (i.e., their farms) to help control their costs.
The TWISUNGANE group don’t have their own land titles. This is an enormous problem because without collateral such as land titles they are not allowed to apply for a loan at the banks for larger business projects.
Additionally, because the group does not have one large farm that they share, each family has their own separate plot. This presents added challenges because family plants, sows, fertilizers, and harvests individually which results in lower yields. This makes it difficult to follow up on their activities because each family is working independently, if they had one common farm they shared, the follow up would be easy and the outcomes would be better.
In recent years, the government of Rwanda has taken steps to make the purchase of small farmland plots much more available to the small farmers. The process of titling and title transfer has been modernized. The government has gotten much land from owners with questionable titles e.g., people who claimed ownership of land after records were destroyed during the 1994 genocide. The government is making such land available for sale to legitimate owners such as the farmers we mentor.
After significant discussions with the Twisungane group about the best business ventures for them they decided upon the business of buying and selling farming plots. This business is good because land or plots have shown higher returns in their village. It is an excellent money-saving investment which will guarantee higher returns in the future.
Investing in a plot of land is undoubtedly one of the best options for the group looking to gain high returns with minimal risk in their area. Also, it will offer greater flexibility, initial investment is low and is estimated to be from 500,000-2000000 frw (~$580 to $2,320). There is no time gap between purchase and possession (new governmental rules and processes allow for same day titling). Lower property tax: the property tax tends to be much lower than it is for other businesses. No maintenance costs: with a plot of land, there is no maintenance needed. One of the biggest advantages of investing in land is that it will be an answer to their fundamental problem of owning the means of production. After repaying the loans, the land will remain theirs and it will be easy for them to manage it easily because it will not require full time supervision.
Challenges and Lessons Learned
Diane has two Twisungane Group business planning classes; the students of both classes are very committed. Farmers who know how to read and write bought notebooks and pens to write down lessons. For those who do not know how to read and write lessons are transmitted orally. Through conversations, with both groups, Diane started to discuss the purpose of being trained as smallholder farmers about business plan development. She shared with them the main purposes of business plan development; business plan development is also a plan of action.
Twisungane Goals
Summary
Tools for Hope is on solid footing with both our capital and human resources. Our overarching goal continues to be the same i.e., to accurately find and develop solutions to the generic problems causing wide-spread poverty in sub-Saharan Africa.
Tools for Hope needs and appreciates your support. Your donations are used to find sustainable solutions to poverty among the most vulnerable. Our expenses are exceptionally low i.e., salary for our Rwandan mentor(s), annual travel to Rwanda (1 person, 1 week, economy), minor expenses related to our website, required legal filing fees, etc. We pay no rent, utilities, administrative salaries, etc.
The Tools for Hope team is dedicated to continuing improvement, especially when we can learn from our experiences. In the past year we have learned the importance of clear communications with our staff in Rwanda as well as the importance of oversight of our remote activities.
2020 Annual ReportWith your support, hard work by the Rwandan farmers, and the wide-ranging advice from Frank Mutesa, Tools for Hope, Inc. (TFH) achieved its primary goals for 2020 and made progress on an added goal toward sustainable development for the Twisungane cooperative. Frank Mutesa, TFH Rwandan employee and mentor to the Twisungane families, led the way in incorporating no-till farming techniques, off-farm income producing projects, and crop and food preservation improvements. Additionally, we made progress supplying adequate, economical, clean water to the cooperative members. Too often they are using water from the river which is dirty, and this has affected their health for so long. During April 2020 Rwanda implemented a nation-wide lockdown in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. During the lockdown TFH supplied rice, corn flour, and cooking oil enough to sustain them for 2 months. Normally, TFH does not give such free aid. However, the COVID-19 problem is unique. TFH supplied the (Rwandan currency) funds to the farmers to buy their food supplies from local Rwandan businesses. Supplying free food to the farmers from outside their country (e.g., from the USA) would have the effect of undermining local businesses. No Rwandan businessperson can compete with free goods and services. In early 2020, Frank began a trial to determine the efficacy of no-till farming for the farmers. He set up six plots, three using no-till farming and three using typical land preparation / farming techniques. Each plot was planted with the same crop (beans), used the same fertilizers and other inputs. The farmers did all the work, TFH guaranteed that the farmers would not lose income if the no-till technique failed, and Frank oversaw the process. The results of the trial showed the superiority of the no-till technique. More food was produced with significantly less labor (the farmers have no farm machinery), lower costs of inputs, and soil fertility was improved. Through 2020 and into 2021 the farmers are now using the no-till technique. Frank has thoroughly trained them in how to sustain this significant improvement to their farming. He also teaches them how to calculate rainfall distribution data from METEO-RWANDA, and how to plan which crops to cultivate and which agricultural system to use as regards the amount of rainfall predicted for the upcoming season. Frank introduced the Participatory Integrated Climate Services for Agriculture (PICSA) approach. The PICSA approach evaluates historical climate information and uses hands-on tools to develop and choose crop, livestock, and livelihood options best suited to individual farmers’ circumstances. In February 2020, Frank and the farmers held discussions on their up-coming goat purchases through loans from Tools for Hope (TFH). The goats were delivered the first of March 2020. Eleven farmer families agreed to the terms of the TFH (one-year+, no interest) loan and each family received two goats (~$60.00 per goat). Their goat project has been going very well, all their goats have given birth. Their goats are being kept in good conditions. The off-farm project of their motorcycle transportation business is doing very well. Their revenue is good, and they continue to pay the loan as agreed upon. So far for repayment of their (no interest) motorbike loan (~$2,600.00), every two weeks they deposit 42,000 Rwanda Francs (~$43.85) into a local TFH bank account. However, their business was suspended during the COVID-19 lockdown. In May, the lockdown in Rwanda ended but with some restrictions still in place. With the end of the lockdown TFH employee, Frank Mutesa, was able to verify the farmer’s activities, to hold meetings, and to give technical support as usual. Because their farms cannot produce enough food and income our smallholder farmers depend on informal day-work. Because of the COVID-19 pandemic measures to minimize travel. Our farmers could not travel to find work. Without income from day-labor and while waiting for their primary crops to mature they were down to one meal or less per day. Crop and food preservation therefore took on added importance. We emphasize the necessity of growing vegetables and fruit trees in their back yards (kitchen gardens) to ensure they get the proper food and thus improve their immune systems as one of the measures to combat the COVID-19 pandemic. Food preservation is one of the most critical problems that the farmers need to solve to combat hunger. Most of their crop yields are lost or were sold at minimum market prices because farmers had no suitable techniques for food preservation. With focus on proper harvesting, effective post-harvest techniques, implementation of preservation techniques such as drying and converting some crops to flour the farmers have been able to significantly extend their food supplies. We will continue to pursue acceptable and practical techniques to further secure their food supply. For the farmers, obtaining clean water is among the difficult issues that they experience all their lives. We bought ceramic water filters to evaluate the viability of ceramic water filtration (ceramic pot-shaped filters with silver embedded in the porous ceramic). We need to find out if this technique will work in our farmer’s area. The Twisungane group families, Frank, and the Tools for Hope, Inc. Board of Directors thank you for your support. We continue to operate with no administrative overhead (no rent, no utilities, no website fees, no USA employees, etc.). Annual Rwandan travel, Frank’s salary, and zero interest loans to the farmers form ~95% of TFH expenses. With you support TFH continues to improve its ability to help more subsistence farmers. The current group has grown from ~15 to ~100 members. We anticipate expanding the group or adding a new group in 2021.
|
The Twisungane group is a group of smallholder farmers living in the Eastern Province of Rwanda, Bugesera district, in the Ntarama sector. Twisungane, the name picked by the farmers for their group means the “Hard Workers”. This group was founded in 2012 by 7 members, all men, who tried to share agricultural activities. They combined their efforts to support their families.
In 2015 when Tools For Hope (TFH) started working with the group, group membership increased to include 10 men, 9 women and 34 children. The farmers recalled that before starting working with TFH, the Twisungane group could barely afford to survive, many of its members had no shelter and were totally dependent on vending locally made beer to earn a living.
Now there are 68 family members of which 15 are men, 13 women and 40 children. Of the 40 children 29 are in primary schools while the remaining 11 are still young but in 2 years they will be all in school.
TFH has improved the standard of living of the Twisungane members through its support of agricultural equipment and training. Working with the TFH mentor (Frank Mutesa) in Rwanda the Twisungane have managed to learn and implement much better agricultural, administrative, and business systems.
Below are some of the benefits;
Getting the basic utility vehicle (BUV) which we purchased from the (Institute for Affordable Transportation backed) manufacturer in Tanzania out to the farmers, without paying the normal taxes on imported vehicles, was our top priority in 2018. This took a long time and quite a bit of work with various Rwandan governmental agencies. Tools For Hope (TFH) wanted to get the BUV imported into Rwanda and then out to the farmers in the most economical way possible. Without tax exemptions the price of the BUV would have doubled from $5,000.00 to approximately $10,000.00.
This BUV was a new import ‘machine’ in Rwanda which meant the government officials were not acquainted with it. Therefore, the first step was to explain to the Ministry of Agriculture (MINAGRI) about the vehicle. We worked with the MINAGRI explaining to them how the BUV would work for the farmers and convincing them to recommend us to the Rwanda Revenue Authority (RRA) /Customs services. This was very difficult as there is list of tools that can be exempted and our BUV was not on that list, originally.
Finally, on the 15th of May 2018 the RRA accepted our request and granted us the VAT exception that we requested. Our hope was that the BUV would add income to the farmers by performing multiple tasks. We believed that this BUV would be able to operate in their rural environment and improve the lifestyle of the farmers.
The farmers began trying to use the BUV for their agriculture transportation and to transport other goods from the market to their villages, as well as transporting water from the river for different uses. Unfortunately, the design of this BUV was challenged by the mountainous topography of this area. This BUV, based on our research on the ground, was designed and manufactured to work on flat terrain (e.g., it has no gears).
Given the vehicle’s limited performance, the farmers did not believe they could generate enough income to pay back a $5,000 loan in 5 years and keep up with maintenance. Frank became very familiar with the problems associated with this BUV because he was the one who was training the farmers to use it. This area is more suitable for a BUV that has gears and especially a reverse gear which are missing on this current BUV.
Twisungane farmers have requested a BUV replacement which is suited to their terrain. The farmers have identified a BUV which is assembled in Rwanda and which costs $3,200. This BUV is now operating near their area, it can withstand the rough mountainous terrain, and it has all the power and gearing it needs for their tasks. They have told TFH this one can meet their needs and they would be able to repay the loan in three years. With the help of this BUV we believe the farmers will be able to get what they need from and to the market, which is very difficult without motorized transportation. The issue is still under investigation.
The Twisungane group now has an elected leadership. They have a president, a vice president, a secretary, and an accountant (cashier).
The president (Samuel UWAMBAJIMANA,) oversees all the activities of the group and meets with Frank Mutesa from Tools For Hope (TFH), helps in partnering with other organizations whether governmental or non-governmental for the wellbeing of the group. He is charged with calling the group meetings which he chairs.
The Vice president (Venust KAMANAYO) is the advisor to the president and performs the role of president when Samuel is not present. The Twisungane group management meeting is twice each agricultural season and more when it is necessary.
The secretary (Claudine NYIRANDIMUBANZI) oversees recording all the important issues in the group’s record book and oversees informing the group members of all necessary information that comes from the group meetings and sees to it that all the effective agendas and schedules are known to the group members.
The accountant/cashier (Celestin GASENDWA) oversees the cash flow and looks for customers for the group’s harvests. She is also in charge of counting the profits and clarifying how the group members will share equally. Celestin is also in charge of collecting member contributions when they have decided a certain activity needs money, for example recently they wanted to buy some good quality irrigation pipes to replace the ones that had worn out. After the general meeting, they decided to raise 75,000 Rwandan francs to buy the pipes. Celestin collected the money from members.
For 2019, the Twisungane farmers have requested that TFH focus more on assisting them with projects and small businesses. TFH is working with the farmers to help them prioritize their proposed projects and to develop basic business plans for each.
Below are some proposed 2019 projects;
Twisungane farmers are now doing great, in fact we have received many requests from other farmers who need to join this group or begin new groups. Other local farmers are now waiting for proposed TFH plans so that they can know how to go about recruiting other members and partnering with other business people. Currently the Twisungane group is looking for partnerships with some business people in order to learn some business and market practices. This will help them in establishing the projects that would boost more their standard of living. TFH is willing to help them in linking with these business people and to help them in management of the project(s) and funding some of the proposed projects.
copyright Tools for Hope, Inc. 2021
"Tools for Hope, Inc." is a 501(c) 3 non-profit Tennessee corporation.
1540 Robinson Road, Knoxville TN 37923